Stefanie Johnston Dual qualified commercial disputes Partner
Ince Scotland: Acquittal secured in marine prosecution - July 2022
Stefanie Johnston, dual-qualified Partner, led the team from Ince, assisted by Iain Franklin, Senior Associate, following a Scottish instruction to act on behalf of Mr. Steven Davie, who was being prosecuted for alleged breaches of the Merchant Shipping Act 1995and The International Regulations for Preventing Collisions at Sea 1972 (“COLREGS”). The defence at trial was conducted by David Nicolson, advocate from Compass Chambers. Mr. Davie’s legal team successfully secured his acquittal at Inverness Sheriff Court.
The trial proceeded in respect of five charges arising out of three incidents which took place on 18 August 2018 in the waters near Eilean Donan castle. It was alleged that Mr. Davie had driven too close and too fast to two other vessels in the first incident and had failed to give way in the second incident. In the third incident, it was alleged that he had again passed too close to other vessels while there were persons in the water.
Captain Dominic Bell, Managing Master Mariner of Brookes Bell, was instructed as an expert witness on behalf of Mr. Davie. Mr. Bell stated that Mr. Davie’s seamanship for the first and third incidents did not fall below an appropriate standard. He had given other vessels sufficient room. As regards the persons in the water during the third incident, Mr. Bell indicated that a sufficiently visible flag to warn other vessels had not been displayed.
In relation to the second incident, Mr. Bell explained to the jury that Mr. Davie’s vessel was the “stand on” vessel under the COLREGS and, therefore, had right of way. It was the duty of the other vessel to give way. Mr. Davie gave evidence to the Court that he had reduced his speed and altered course to avoid a collision, when it became apparent that the “give-way” vessel had not acted appropriately.
Following the sheriff’s charge, the jury found Mr. Davie not guilty of all five charges in a little over an hour.
Stefanie Johnston from Ince commented:
“We are delighted with the outcome of this case. We are fortunate to have a team of Master Mariners at Ince that really add value for our clients, as well as the excellent input from our expert witness Dominic Bell from Brookes Bell."
Our newly established office in Scotland has been well received by clients who benefit from our global expertise where they need us. To learn more about our Glasgow office, click here.
Related news & insights
News / Ince celebrates one year since Scotland office opening
23-11-2022 / Insurance, Maritime, Real Estate
We are pleased to be celebrating one year since opening our first Scottish office in the city of Glasgow. Stefanie Johnston, dual-qualified Partner and Head of Scotland, has worked tirelessly over the last year to develop our offering through the opening of an Ince office in what is arguably an established Scottish market. Starting from the ground up, Stefanie and her team have successfully gained an admirable reputation in the region and further afield in the maritime, insurance, real estate and regulatory sectors.
News / Shipping E-brief November 2022
17-11-2022 / Maritime
The Shipping E-Brief is a publication providing you with key information on legal decisions and developments in shipping and related business areas.
News / Appeals from arbitration: is reform required?
15-11-2022 / Maritime
In September 2022, the UK Law Commission published a consultation paper with provisional recommendations for updating the Arbitration Act 1996 (the Act 1996). Amongst other things, the Law Commission considered whether any changes need to be made to: (i) s.67 of the Act 1996, which deals with jurisdictional challenges to arbitral awards; and (ii) s.69 of the Act 1996, which deals with appeals on points of law.
News / Owners not in breach of charter and entitled to claim demurrage
09-11-2022 / Maritime
CM P-MAX III Limited v. Petroleos Del Norte SA (MT Stena Primorsk)  EWHC 2147 (Comm) This recent laytime and demurrage dispute demonstrates that an owner can legitimately refuse orders where such orders may jeopardise the safety of a vessel.
News / Court of Appeal finds owner should have accepted non-contractual performance
09-11-2022 / Maritime
Mur Shipping BV v. RTI Ltd  EWCA Civ 1406 A majority of the Court of Appeal has held that the Owner under a contract of affreightment (COA) should have accepted payment of freight in Euros, rather than the US dollars provided for in the COA. Its refusal to do so meant that the Owner could not rely on the force majeure clause in the COA, in circumstances where US sanctions might have restricted US dollar transfers from or on behalf of the Charterer.
News / “Due” means due!
03-11-2022 / Maritime
Ceto Shipping Corporation v. Savory Inc (Victor 1)  EWHC 2636 (Comm) The Court in this case had to construe a purchase option clause in a bareboat charter. Specifically, it considered whether the fact that the charterer had not fulfilled certain payment obligations under the charter because it was disputing them in good faith meant that the owner was not obliged to transfer title to the vessel at the end of the charter period.