Menu
Inheritance Dispute: What happens when a married couple die together?

Insights / / Bristol

When a married couple are found dead together, who is entitled to inherit their estates?  Laura Ramos, Trainee Solicitor in Private Client, explains how the law operates in these cases.

You would have recently read in the news that two stepsisters found themselves in this position when their parents died together and the Court could not determine who had died first.

Mr and Mrs Scarle, 79 and 69 years old respectively, were found dead together from hypothermia at their bungalow in Essex three years ago. Mr Scarle’s only child from a previous relationship, Ms Winter, and Mrs Scarle’s daughter, Ms Cutler, had to demonstrate who had died first in order to establish who was entitled to inherit their jointly owned estate.

In cases such as this one, there is a presumption under section 184 of the Law of Property Act 1925 that the younger survived the elder and therefore the elder’s estate passes free of inheritance tax to the younger and the estate of the younger (to include the elder spouse’s assets) passes to the beneficiaries under their Will or under the intestacy rules if the deceased died without a Will.

In the above case, Ms Cutler had to demonstrate that the presumption applied and that Mrs Scarle, being the younger, had survived her elder husband, Mr Scarle, so she could inherit her mother’s and Mr Scarle’s estate. The parties obtained pathology reports but the Court was not able to determine who had died first. Finally, the judge concluded that the presumption applied and Mrs Scarle had survived her husband, therefore both estates passed under her Will and her daughter, Ms Cutler, was entitled to her estate.

How we can assist

This case demonstrates the importance of making mirror Wills containing the same provisions, particularly if there are children from previous relationships, or to consider making Wills incorporating Life Interest Trust so that you can make provision for your spouse and control the destination of your capital on your spouse’s death, for the benefit of your children.

The Wills that we prepare in our Private Client team are drafted to incorporate the presumption under section 184 of the Law of Property Act 1925 and to take advantage of the inheritance tax position so that the estate of the elder spouse can pass free of inheritance tax in circumstances where a married couple have died together and it could not be established who had died first.

Our Private Client department offers Wills, Probate, Tax & Trusts services. We offer a 30 minute free consultation and we will be pleased to discuss your personal and financial circumstances with you so that we can provide you with a bespoke advice that best suits your needs.

Related services:

Quick links

The Legal 500 2021

“Very available and responsive to company developments in real time. Frank, clear advice – not just the ‘easy’ answer.”

The Legal 500 2022

“The solicitors who have handled our employment related issues are of the highest quality in terms of their specialist area of expertise, their professionalism and their approach to us as clients and as people. Special mention has to be made of Laura Livingstone. Laura became a key member of our team and felt more like a colleague than an external adviser – a colleague you could rely upon. Laura’s attention to detail, professionalism and responsiveness was second to none. Laura has come to know and understand us as individuals and this has enabled her to personalise her advice and even sometimes to preempt our future requirements. We have a very special and extremely valuable relationship with her and the firm.”

- The Legal 500

The Legal 500 2022

“Ince are an excellent “fit” with our specific needs. The firm has consistently provided a broad range of personnel-related advice and in our experience that advice has been consistently of the very highest professional standard: it has been timely, comprehensive, accurate and at a cost which is commensurate with the budget of an organisation of our size.”

- The Legal 500

The Legal 500 2022

“The firm has an unusually high degree of insight into the practices and policies required by the Gambling Commission as regards compliance with its own requirements and conditions – particularly Andrew Tait, derived from his previous in-house experience.”

- The Legal 500