Menu
Vedanta to be sued by Zambian claimants in English Courts

News / / Vedanta to be sued by Zambian claimants in English Courts

That said, the specific facts of the case must be considered The claimants, from rural farming communities in Zambia, are pursuing Konkola Copper Mines (KCM) and its UK-based ultimate parent company Vedanta in the English courts Both defendants disputed jurisdiction on a number of grounds including abuse of EU law and a lack of real issue against Vedanta (which is the anchor' defendant for the purposes of establishing jurisdiction in England) The Supreme Court held that the claimants are allowed to bring their claim against the defendants in the English courts This is in spite of the fact that the Supreme Court held that the claimants failed to demonstrate that England is the proper place for the trial of their claims A vital factor in the Supreme Court finding for the claimants is the fact that the defendant companies failed on the substantial justice issue the judge had not misdirected himself in law in finding that the claimants would be deprived of substantial justice if the claims were brought in Zambia (due to lack of funding and the necessary legal resources to run their claims) and to challenge the previous decisions otherwise would be to try to overturn judicial fact-finding While the case turns on its specific facts and the appellate court's reluctance to overturn findings of fact, this judgment arguably paves the way for more foreign claimants to seek to establish jurisdiction in the English courts Whether this leads to an increase in opportunistic claims being filed in this jurisdiction while the Brussels Recast Regulation is still applicable in English law (given an impending though postponed Brexit) remains to be seen As an aside, the Supreme Court with an element of exasperation emphasised the requirement of proportionality in relation to jurisdiction appeal and noted the disproportionate way in which the jurisdiction issue had been litigated in this case

Related sectors:

Related services:

Related news & insights

News / Widely worded no-assignment clause shuts out insurer’s claims

24-01-2023 / Insurance

An insurer that paid out on a claim brought by its assured, the buyer of aircraft under an English law sale contract, has been prevented from making a recovery against the seller because the sale contract incorporated a widely worded no-assignment clause.

Widely worded no-assignment clause shuts out insurer’s claims

News / Ince celebrates one year since Scotland office opening

23-11-2022 / Insurance, Maritime, Real Estate

We are pleased to be celebrating one year since opening our first Scottish office in the city of Glasgow.  Stefanie Johnston, dual-qualified Partner and Head of Scotland, has worked tirelessly over the last year to develop our offering through the opening of an Ince office in what is arguably an established Scottish market. Starting from the ground up, Stefanie and her team have successfully gained an admirable reputation in the region and further afield in the maritime, insurance, real estate and regulatory sectors. 

Ince celebrates one year since Scotland office opening

News / Anti-suit injunction to restrain breach of London arbitration agreement in insurance policy

09-11-2022 / Insurance

QBE Europe SA/NV and another v. Generali Espana de Seguros y Reaseguros [2022] EWHC 2062 (Comm) In this case, a Spanish insurer sought to assert a direct right of action against a UK insurer in Spanish proceedings. The English Court found that the Spanish proceedings had been brought in contravention of a London arbitration agreement in the relevant liability insurance policy and granted an anti-suit injunction to restrain those proceedings.

Anti-suit injunction to restrain breach of London arbitration agreement in insurance policy

Insights / Countdown to COP27: recent developments

04-11-2022 / Energy & Infrastructure, Insurance

As we get ready for COP27, we've prepared a summary some of the key developments relating to climate and environmental policies over the last few weeks.

Countdown to COP27: recent developments

News / Dan Crockford appointed as Head of Office for Ince (Bristol)

23-06-2022 / Insurance

We are delighted to announce that Dan Crockford has recently been appointed as Head of Office for Ince (Bristol).

Dan Crockford appointed as Head of Office for Ince (Bristol)

News / Court construes scope of indemnity under Mortgagees’ Interest Insurance Policy

06-06-2022 / Insurance, Maritime

Piraeus Bank A.E. v Antares Underwriting Limited and others (The ZouZou) [2022] EWHC 1169 (Comm)

Court construes scope of indemnity under Mortgagees’ Interest Insurance Policy