Fixing of domestic airfares by Indian government: a mode to be replicated by other countries?
Setting aside our aspersions on the manner in which domestic air travel was recommenced in India – by way of a tweet by the aviation minister catching the airlines unawares - the government’s decision to “control” the ticket prices, at least in the short term (3 months), is, I feel, a masterstroke.
Just from a policy perspective, the government has consistently maintained that it is against capping of airfares in any form in India, citing that the competition amongst the airlines will take care of any pricing concerns. It is imperative to point out that price controls are usually counterproductive in the long run. Price controls typically tent to lead to problems of shortages, rationing, deterioration of product quality, and even black markets and thus, the Indian government had previously avoid the temptation of setting prices and, instead, allowed the airline market to function independently through the auspices of demand and supply.
However, with the instant announcement, the Indian government has ‘bit the bullet’ and has taken a stoic position, albeit in the short term. Seemingly, the government’s position stems from two poignant reasons: First, to ensure that the airline tickets do not become overtly priced for the consumer, and second, to dissuade / prevent the ‘stronger’ airlines from using their deeper pockets to indulge in predatory pricing.
Issues of “predatory pricing” have to be analysed by considering various factors including, without limitation, market power, cost structures etc. That is the topic for a separate discussion and is not under the purview of the current commentary.
While we appreciate that the Covid-19 situation has thrown the Indian economy (and indeed the world economy) into turmoil, we also know that extraordinary times call for extraordinary measures, and this is where the government’s initiative to ‘cap the airfares’, seems to be a step in the right direction, as it should ease the airlines into staggered operations without any undue financial burden on the paying customers.
With the easing of the movement control order and the commencement of domestic air travel, passengers can look forward to returning to the ‘new normal’ – both professionally as well as to meet with their loved ones. The airlines, on the other hand, have to ensure adherence to safety protocols like additional aircraft sanitisation requirements, temperature screenings, reduced capacity owing to social-distancing protocols etc. Be that as it may, domestic flights taking off in India are welcome in today’s economy, especially for the airlines who have been bleeding money for the last two months. It is a widely-recognised principle in the aviation circle that an aircraft in the air is always significantly better than grounded aircraft. Thus, even with reduced capacity, the airlines would be somewhat in a better position than what they’ve been facing in the recent past.
Whilst all of us, passengers as well as the airlines, would love to be in the pre-coronavirus era, it is safe to say that the onset of the 21st century has not been a very happy one. With the government’s initiative to re-start domestic flights with the requisite price controls in place, it is hoped (rather than expected) that the Indian economy would slowly revive, if not to the pre-virus levels, then at least to a level from where it can jumpstart, as and when the coronavirus situation improves globally.
In fact, the Indian government’s decision of price controls for the short term, can and indeed should, be replicated by other larger countries having substantial ‘domestic travel’ opportunities.
 Supra, at 3 above
新闻 / Aviation insurance post EU Reg 2022/328 and the imminent UK mirror legislation
09-03-2022 / 航空和旅游
It is a difficult fact of life that crises such as the present one in Ukraine cause not only human losses and suffering of the most grievous kind, but also extreme challenges for commercial entities and sectors, and their insurers. Recent events have demonstrated yet again how crucial insurance is to all commercial operations, none more so than the Aviation, Aerospace and Space sectors. It is a sign of the current challenging geopolitical landscape that we expect certain market clauses will come under scrutiny again after many years without disputes.
洞察力 / A flying start for the restructuring plan
06-01-2021 / 航空和旅游
Alex Rogan looks at the maiden flight of the restructuring plan, highlighting the practical considerations for future cases.
新闻 / Incisive Law featured on the September issue of Asian Legal Business
18-09-2020 / 航空和旅游
We are pleased to have been featured in the September issue of the Asian Legal Business Magazine.
洞察力 / Counter-Drone Tech and the Challenges Thereof
27-08-2020 / 航空和旅游
Drone detection technologies have been a blind spot for most governments across the world, and it gains significance in the current times considering that drones are now being used for commercial purposes.
洞察力 / Drones – A New Frontier
13-08-2020 / 航空和旅游
Unmanned Aircraft Systems / Vehicles (UAS UAV - or Drones, as they are commonly known) refer primarily to an unmanned aircraft which is guided by a remote control.
新闻 / Update on the impact of the Coronavirus on the Aviation Industry
06-03-2020 / 航空和旅游
Impact The COVID-19 outbreak has already had a severe impact on the aviation sector. “Air traffic has collapsed on key Asian routes and it is rippling throughout the air transport network globally, even between countries without major outbreaks of COVID-19.” Flybe yesterday announced its collapse, in part it says due to the effect of coronavirus upon bookings. Airlines are experiencing a serious decline in demand: “one carrier has taken a 26% reduction in passenger numbers across its entire operation and a major carrier has reported booking to Italy collapsing to zero with customers demanding refunds. Many carriers are reporting 50% no-shows across several markets, future bookings are softening and carriers are reacting with flight cancellation, crew being given unpaid leave, freezing of pay increases and plans for aircraft to be grounded.”