What Are The Legal Implications Surrounding Surrogacy?

News / / Cardiff

As many of the listeners of the radio 4 soap, The Archers, will be aware, the characters Ian and Adam are navigating the issues surrounding the birth of their son Xander, through surrogacy. The story of Adam and Ian using the services of a surrogate unfolded during 2019, and in September 2019 their Son Xander was born.

The use of this storyline in such a high profile and popular radio soap demonstrates how surrogacy has become more prominent, openly talked about and accepted as an opportunity for different family structures to be able to have a child of their own.

Surrogacy is where an individual or a couple, whether they are a heterosexual or same sex couple, nominate another woman to give birth to a child on their behalf.

Over the last 7 years, the recorded number of children born through surrogacy has more than doubled.

In the majority of cases surrogacy unfolds without any difficulties and it is a smooth process for all, with the overwhelming feeling that the act of surrogacy is a gift from the surrogate to the intended parents for them to experience having their own child.

However sadly, there are examples where both the intended parents or the surrogate mother are treated poorly giving rise to serious concerns to all involved including the child.

Surrogacy gives rise to ethical and legal issues, but at the heart of it, is the wellbeing of the child which has to come first.

Surrogacy in the UK is regulated with rules and laws about what is and isn’t permitted. For example, it is not permitted for a surrogate to be paid for having a child, although, reasonable expenses such as medical fees can be paid for. Other examples are that Surrogates cannot advertise that the offer surrogacy as a service and whilst those involved may set out or record the arrangements in writing, any such record is not legally binding in the UK.

When the child is born the surrogate mother is the legal parent. To transfer the legal parenthood an application to the court for a parental order has to be made and when it is granted the child becomes the legal child of the intended parents and the surrogate at that point loses all legal rights in respect of the child. This is the stage that the Characters Ian and Adam in the Archers are at, and they are now going through the court process. This can be a long process during which time the surrogate retains parental responsibility for a child that is being brought up by the intended parents. This is generally regarded as unsatisfactory and it is one of many issues that is being considered for reform following a Law Commission investigation into Surrogacy and making the whole process fit for purpose.

Surrogacy brings joy and happiness to individuals and couples who long for a child of their own, as the characters of Adam and Ian are experiencing, however it also can bring with it legal issues that have to be dealt with.

Ince provides a full service for advising and representing clients who are either, wanting to become parents or are the surrogate and are considering surrogacy or are already going through surrogacy. Whatever your circumstance we have a specialist solicitor who will support, advise and represent you as you navigate the issues surrounding surrogacy.

Further information can be obtained by contacting me by phone, email or via the Ince social media platforms.

Susan J Williams

Susan J Williams Partner and Head of Family Department

Related services: